Skip to content

G.63Collections

How to Collect Unpaid Invoices: Steps Before You Call a Lawyer

An escalation path for invoices that reminders haven't fixed, with the records to keep at each stage and the questions to put to a professional.

By PayLinkPublished 8 min read

On this page9 sections
  1. 01Step 1: check the invoice is collectible
  2. 02Step 2: build the paper trail
  3. 03Step 3: escalate on a schedule
  4. 04Step 4: offer a way to pay
  5. 05Step 5: pause further work
  6. 06Step 6: send a formal demand letter
  7. 07Step 7: decide whether to bring in professionals
  8. 08Step 8: write off what you can't collect
  9. 09Frequently asked questions

To collect an unpaid invoice, first confirm the customer actually has a correct invoice they can pay. Then follow up on a fixed schedule, escalating from your contact to a decision-maker, and offer a payment plan before anything formal. If that fails, send a written demand. Only after that weigh a collection agency, small claims court or an attorney, against what the debt is worth.

Definition

Unpaid invoices are invoices that remain outstanding after their due date. Until they are paid, settled or written off, they sit in accounts receivable as money the business has earned but not received, and the older they get, the harder they usually are to collect.

The steps below are ordered by cost: each one costs more than the one before, in fees or in goodwill, so you only go as far as the account requires. Nothing here is legal advice. Where the law matters, and it starts to matter at step six, talk to an attorney in your state.

The worked example is hypothetical. An engineering consultancy is owed $14,500 by a property developer: invoice 318 for $9,000 is 52 days past due and invoice 331 for $5,500 is 22 days past due.

Step 1: check the invoice is collectible

Some "unpaid" invoices are ones the customer cannot pay as sent. Before you escalate anything, check:

  • It went to the address or portal the customer uses for invoices, not just to the project contact.
  • It carries any purchase order or job number the customer requires.
  • The amount matches the contract, the quote or the approved change order.
  • The customer's legal name is correct, and so is the entity you contracted with if they have several.
  • Any paperwork their AP team needs, such as a W-9 or lien waiver, has been supplied.

In the example, the developer's AP team rejected invoice 318 three weeks ago because it lacked a PO number, and nobody told the consultancy. Fixing that resets the conversation without anyone losing face.

Step 2: build the paper trail

Every step from here on is stronger with records behind it. Keep a single file per account containing:

  • The signed contract, proposal or accepted quote, including the payment terms.
  • Each invoice as sent, with proof of delivery (the email, or the portal confirmation).
  • Evidence the work was delivered or accepted: sign-offs, delivery receipts, emails approving drafts.
  • Every reminder and reply, with dates, plus notes of each phone call: who you spoke to, what they said, what they promised.
  • Any partial payments received.

Write call notes on the day. "Spoke to J. Ruiz, AP, 14 May, said invoice 318 approved and will go in the 28 May payment run" is worth far more later than a recollection.

Step 3: escalate on a schedule

Follow-up works when it is regular and gets steadily more senior. A typical path, assuming net 30 terms:

  1. Days 1 to 15 past due: reminders to your contact and the AP team, each with a payment link.
  2. Around day 30: a firm email and a phone call asking for a payment date.
  3. Around day 45: a letter or email from your owner to theirs, or to their controller.
  4. Around day 60: a final notice with a deadline and the next step you'll take.

Our past due invoice email templates give wording for each stage. If you handle many accounts, a written dunning process keeps the schedule consistent across them.

Step 4: offer a way to pay

A customer who is short of cash will often pay something if you make it easy, and nothing if you insist on everything. Propose a plan in writing, with dates and amounts. For the developer, that might be:

PaymentDateAmountBalance after
1On signing the plan$4,500$10,000
230 days later$3,500$6,500
360 days later$3,500$3,000
490 days later$3,000$0

Get the customer to sign or accept the plan in writing, and state what happens if a payment is missed (for example, that the remaining balance becomes due at once). Wherever possible, collect each instalment automatically from a card or bank account the customer authorizes, so the plan doesn't depend on them remembering. Invoices that accept partial payments also help, because the customer can pay what they can without a new invoice being raised each time.

Step 5: pause further work

If you still provide services to a customer who isn't paying, your exposure keeps growing. Many businesses stop new work, hold deliveries or move the customer to payment in advance until the account is current. Check what your contract allows before you do; stopping work on a project mid-way can create its own disputes. Tell the customer in writing, calmly, and say what will restart work.

Step 6: send a formal demand letter

A demand letter is the last communication from you before someone else gets involved. It is usually sent by email and by a tracked postal method, so you can show it was received. It should set out:

  • The invoices, amounts and due dates, and the total owed.
  • A summary of your previous contacts, with dates.
  • A firm deadline for payment, typically a set number of days from the letter.
  • What you will do if the deadline passes, stated plainly and only if you intend to do it.
  • How to pay, using the same payment details as before.

Some businesses have their attorney send the demand instead. A letter on a law firm's letterhead costs more, and it tends to be taken more seriously. Ask an attorney what your letter should and shouldn't say in your state.

Step 7: decide whether to bring in professionals

Once your own efforts are exhausted, you can hand the account to someone else. Each option suits a different size of debt, and the rules for each depend on your state. A few points worth knowing before you call anyone:

  • Collection agencies often work on contingency, keeping a share of what they recover. Ask for the fee in writing and what the agency will and won't do on your behalf.
  • Small claims court is meant for smaller disputes, up to a dollar limit that varies by state. Your state court's website lists the limit and explains how to file.
  • An attorney can advise on the strength of your claim and, if it comes to that, file suit. For large debts this is often the only sensible route.

If your customers are individuals rather than businesses, there is another layer. The FTC describes the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act as covering consumer debts, those incurred for personal, family or household purposes, and as prohibiting third-party debt collectors from deceptive or abusive conduct when collecting them. State laws may add rules of their own. Choose an agency that knows the rules for the kind of debt you're handing over.

Is the invoice worth pursuing?

Put a number on it before you start. Take a smaller, separate example: a $3,200 invoice. If an agency's contingency fee were 25% (a hypothetical figure; get real quotes), a full recovery would bring you $2,400 ($3,200 × 75%). If you think there is only an even chance of recovering anything, the expected value is about $1,200 ($2,400 × 50%). Set that against your own time and the likely end of the customer relationship. Sometimes the answer is to pursue it on principle; sometimes it's to write it off and tighten your credit policy so it doesn't happen again.

Step 8: write off what you can't collect

An invoice you will never collect shouldn't sit in receivables indefinitely, because it distorts your aging report and your DSO. Writing it off removes it from the books; it does not stop you collecting if the customer later pays.

The tax treatment is a question for your accountant, but the IRS's own summary in Topic 453 gives the outline. A business bad debt is deductible only if the amount was included in your gross income in the current or a prior year. A debt is worthless when there is no reasonable expectation it will be repaid, and you must show you took reasonable steps to collect it, although you don't have to go to court if a judgment would be uncollectible. The same page notes that cash-method taxpayers generally can't deduct unpaid fees and similar items, because that income was never reported. That is one more reason to keep the paper trail from step 2.

Once the account is closed, look back at it. Was there an early sign, such as a first invoice paid late or a disputed line nobody resolved? Your accounts receivable aging report is where those signs show up first. Habits that prevent the next bad debt, like deposits for new customers and a pay button on every invoice, cost less than any of steps 6 to 8. With invoicing set up through PayLink, invoices are scheduled and payment requests go out automatically, by email or text, and customers can choose from more than ten ways to pay.

Frequently asked questions

Q.01

Can I charge interest on an unpaid invoice?

Usually only if the customer agreed to it in advance, in your contract or the terms on your quote and invoice. State laws can limit the rate or the fee you can charge, and rules may differ for consumer and business customers. Have an attorney review the wording before you rely on it. Our guide to late payment fees covers the options.

Q.02

How long do I have to collect an unpaid invoice?

The time limit for suing over an unpaid debt is set by each state's statute of limitations, and it can depend on whether the agreement was written or oral. An attorney in your state can tell you the period that applies. In practice, chase early: the older an invoice is, the harder it tends to be to collect, whatever the legal deadline.

Q.03

What if the customer disputes only part of the invoice?

Ask them to pay the undisputed portion now, and deal with the disputed part separately. Put the split in writing. Resolving the dispute might mean a partial credit or some re-done work. Keeping the two apart stops a small disagreement from holding up the whole balance.

Sources

Talk to us

Talk to us about late payments.

Book a free consultation and talk through how this applies to your business. If you have a recent processing statement, bring it along.