Skip to content

G.32Receivables

How Your Credit Policy Affects Profitability

Longer terms can win sales and still lose money. A worked test shows where the break-even sits, followed by the parts every written policy needs.

By PayLinkPublished 6 min read

On this page5 sections
  1. 01Why credit terms are a profit decision
  2. 02Testing a change in terms: a worked example
  3. 03What early payment discounts really cost
  4. 04What a written credit policy should cover
  5. 05How to tell if your credit policy is working

A credit policy affects profitability by trading extra sales against two costs: financing the larger receivables balance that longer terms create, and the bad debt that comes with weaker accounts. Looser terms can lift revenue while lowering profit, because existing customers start paying later too. Before changing terms, put a dollar figure on the extra gross profit and on both costs.

Definition

A credit policy is a business's written set of rules for selling on credit. It decides which customers qualify and for how much, sets the payment terms, and lays out what happens when an invoice goes unpaid. Between businesses it is often called a trade credit policy; the rules as applied to individual accounts are sometimes called a customer credit policy.

Why credit terms are a profit decision

Most businesses set terms by habit or by matching a competitor. Net 30 because everyone does net 30; net 45 because the big account asked for it. But each extra day of terms is a day you are lending your customer the price of the goods, interest-free. Whether that loan pays for itself depends on how much additional business it brings in and what the money costs you.

The cost of the money is your weighted average cost of capital: the blended return your lenders and owners require. If you haven't worked yours out, your credit line rate is a rough lower bound, and the true figure is usually higher once the owners' required return is included.

Testing a change in terms: a worked example

Say a packaging supplier sells boxes and film to food producers. It currently offers net 30 to every account. A competitor offers net 45, and the sales team believes matching it would add $400,000 a year in new business. Here are the supplier's figures, all hypothetical:

Current (net 30)Proposed (net 45)
Annual credit sales$3,000,000$3,400,000
Days sales outstanding3852
Average receivables (sales × DSO ÷ 365)$312,329$484,384
Bad debt rate0.5%1.2%
Gross margin on sales25%25%
Cost of capital12%12%

The supplier expects DSO to rise by 14 days, roughly in line with the 15-day extension, because existing customers will take the extra time too. Now price the change:

  1. Extra gross profit: $400,000 × 25% = $100,000.
  2. Extra carrying cost: receivables rise by $484,384 − $312,329 = $172,055. At 12%, that costs $20,647 a year.
  3. Extra bad debt: 1.2% × $3,400,000 = $40,800, against 0.5% × $3,000,000 = $15,000 now. The increase is $25,800.
  4. Extra collection costs: more accounts and more overdue balances to manage, say $12,000 a year in staff time.
  5. Net effect: $100,000 − $20,647 − $25,800 − $12,000 = $41,553 more profit a year.

On these assumptions the change pays. Some textbooks value the extra receivables at cost rather than at the selling price, which lowers the carrying cost a little; the conclusion here is the same either way.

Where it stops paying

The whole result rests on the $400,000 forecast. Run it again with half the new sales, $200,000, and everything else unchanged:

  • Extra gross profit: $200,000 × 25% = $50,000.
  • Receivables: $3,200,000 × 52 ÷ 365 = $455,890, an increase of $143,561, costing $17,227 a year.
  • Bad debt: 1.2% × $3,200,000 = $38,400, an increase of $23,400.
  • Collection costs: $12,000.
  • Net effect: $50,000 − $17,227 − $23,400 − $12,000 = −$2,627.

At half the forecast, the supplier is working harder to earn less. Break-even sits at roughly $212,000 of new sales. That is the figure to put to the sales team: how confident are they of beating it?

In both versions, bad debt costs more than carrying the receivables, and it grows on the entire book once looser terms attract weaker accounts. A policy that offers longer terms only to customers who pass a credit check keeps most of the sales benefit and much less of that risk.

What early payment discounts really cost

Discounts for paying early, such as 2/10 net 30 (2% off if paid within 10 days, otherwise due in 30), look like a cheap way to bring cash in. Priced as a rate, they are expensive.

A customer who takes the discount pays 98% of the invoice 20 days early. The cost to you, as an annual rate, is (2 ÷ 98) × (365 ÷ 20) = 37.2%. If customers were actually paying at day 38 rather than day 30, the discount buys 28 days, and the rate falls to (2 ÷ 98) × (365 ÷ 28) = 26.6%. Both figures are far above the supplier's 12% cost of capital. Unless cash is critically short, borrowing on a credit line would be cheaper. Our guide to 2/10 net 30 works through when the discount does make sense.

What a written credit policy should cover

A credit policy only works if it is written down and applied the same way to every account. It doesn't need to be long. A two-page document covering these points is enough for most small and mid-size businesses:

  1. Who qualifies for credit. For example, new accounts complete a credit application with trade and bank references; accounts below a set size, or without references, pay by card or ACH at the time of order.
  2. How credit limits are set. A simple rule ties the limit to expected purchases. A customer expected to buy $20,000 a month on net 30 might get a limit of $30,000, about six weeks of purchases, so that one late payment doesn't stop their next order.
  3. Standard terms and exceptions. State the default (such as net 30), who can approve longer terms, and what an account must show to earn them.
  4. Deposits and payment security. Large custom orders require a deposit. Smaller accounts can keep a card or bank account on file to be charged on the due date; our guide to card on file payments explains the authorization this needs.
  5. Collection steps. When reminders go out, when someone calls, when new orders are put on hold, and who decides.
  6. Late fees. Whether you charge them and how they are disclosed. Rules on late fees vary, so confirm yours with an attorney; our guide to late payment fees covers the practical side.
  7. Reviews. How often limits are reviewed (annually for most accounts, sooner for any customer whose payments slip).

How to tell if your credit policy is working

Three measures tell you whether the policy matches the profit test above. Watch days sales outstanding against your standard terms: a gap that widens means the terms on paper aren't the terms customers are taking. Track bad debt written off as a share of credit sales each year. And look at how sales split between accounts on terms and accounts paying up front. If almost every sale is on credit, the qualifying rules may be too loose; if very few are, you may be turning away buyers who would have paid.

Revisit the policy once a year with real figures in place of the forecasts. The supplier in the example should check, a year after switching to net 45, whether new sales actually cleared the break-even. If they didn't, the policy can change back for new accounts without disturbing customers who have earned the longer terms.

Talk to us

Talk to us about how long you wait to get paid.

Book a free consultation and talk through how this applies to your business. If you have a recent processing statement, bring it along.