Skip to content

G.43Payment methods

ACH vs Credit Card Payments: Which Should You Offer?

Cards cost more and customers find them easy. ACH costs less and carries different risks. Invoice size usually settles the question.

By PayLinkPublished 6 min read

On this page6 sections
  1. 01What each costs at three invoice sizes
  2. 02Speed to cash
  3. 03Disputes and returns work differently
  4. 04What customers want: B2B and consumer
  5. 05Offering cards without absorbing the whole cost
  6. 06A simple way to decide

Offer both if you can, and steer large invoices toward ACH. Card processing costs are mostly a percentage of each sale, so they climb with invoice size, while ACH is often priced per payment or with a capped percentage. Cards give you an approval at the moment of payment; ACH settles in about a banking day and can still come back afterward. The right mix depends on your typical invoice.

Definition

An ACH payment draws money directly from a customer's bank account through the ACH Network, under the Nacha Operating Rules. A credit card payment draws on a line of credit from the customer's card issuer and runs through a card network such as Visa or Mastercard, whose rules govern disputes and surcharges.

The comparison below starts with cost, which is where most owners begin. The bigger surprise is usually what happens when a customer contests a payment.

What each costs at three invoice sizes

Take two hypothetical price lists: cards at an all-in 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction, and ACH at 0.8% capped at $5. Neither is a quote; your own rates are on your processing statement or in your provider's pricing. The shape is what matters.

InvoiceCard cost (2.9% + $0.30)ACH cost (0.8%, max $5)Difference
$95 service call$2.76 + $0.30 = $3.06$0.76$2.30
$1,800 project invoice$52.20 + $0.30 = $52.50$14.40, capped at $5.00$47.50
$22,000 B2B balance$638.00 + $0.30 = $638.30$176.00, capped at $5.00$633.30

On a $95 payment, the gap is small enough that convenience can reasonably win. On the larger invoices, the card fee is roughly 10 to 128 times the ACH fee. With this ACH pricing, the cap kicks in at $625 ($5 ÷ 0.8%), so every invoice above that costs the same $5 to collect by ACH, however large it is.

Now scale it up. Say a firm invoices $600,000 a year in 300 invoices of about $2,000. If every customer paid by card, processing would cost $17,490 ($600,000 × 2.9% = $17,400, plus 300 × $0.30 = $90). If 60% of those invoices, 180 of them worth $360,000, moved to ACH:

  1. Card cost removed: $360,000 × 2.9% + 180 × $0.30 = $10,494.
  2. ACH cost added: 180 × $5 = $900.
  3. Net saving: $10,494 − $900 = $9,594 a year.

Card costs vary by card type and by how you are priced, which is explained in credit card processing fees. The direction of the result rarely changes, though: the bigger the invoice, the more ACH saves.

Speed to cash

A card payment is approved or declined while the customer waits, so you know immediately whether it worked. The money then reaches your bank account on your processor's funding schedule, which you should get in writing.

An ACH debit has no instant approval. Nacha's rules have it settle on the same day or the next banking day, and most ACH payments settle within one banking day. But you learn about a problem only afterward: a debit returned for insufficient funds can come back up to two banking days after settlement. So a card tells you sooner whether you have been paid, while ACH tells you later and more cheaply. If you release goods on payment, that difference matters more than the settlement date. The full timeline is in how long an ACH transfer takes.

Disputes and returns work differently

This is the part that surprises people. A card dispute and an ACH return both take money back out of your account, but they rest on different grounds and run on different clocks.

Credit card disputeACH return
How it startsThe cardholder contacts its card issuer, which sends the transaction back through the network to your acquirerThe customer's bank returns the entry with a reason code
GroundsVisa lists examples such as not recognizing the charge, not receiving the product or service, or believing something went wrongAccount problems (such as insufficient funds or a closed account) and authorization problems
Time limitsSet by the network's rules for each type of disputeTwo banking days after settlement for most returns and for business accounts; up to 60 days for a consumer's unauthorized claim
Your responseYou may submit supporting documents through your acquirer, within strict deadlinesA return made within the rules generally isn't contested through the network; you resolve it with the customer

Two practical consequences follow. First, a card can be disputed over the quality of the work or the goods, while Nacha's return reasons are about the account and the authorization, not about whether the customer was happy. Second, a debit from a business account becomes hard to return once its two-day window has passed, while a consumer's debit stays open to an unauthorized claim for up to 60 days. For card disputes in detail, see what a chargeback is.

What customers want: B2B and consumer

Consumers paying a small bill tend to reach for a card. It's quick and familiar, and it lets them pay you now and their card issuer later. Asking a homeowner to type in a routing number for a $95 call adds friction for a saving of a couple of dollars.

Business customers paying large invoices have different constraints. A $22,000 balance may be above the credit limit on the card the customer's office manager holds. Some accounts payable teams pay vendors only from the bank, by ACH credit, as part of a regular payment run. Others like paying by card for the extra days of credit it gives them, and will happily do so if you absorb the fee. That last group is where your pricing choices come in.

Offering cards without absorbing the whole cost

You don't have to choose between accepting cards and losing margin on them. Visa and Mastercard publish rules under which a merchant may add a surcharge to credit card transactions, and some states restrict or prohibit surcharging; our guide to credit card surcharges covers the rules as the networks publish them. Dual pricing, which shows a card price and a cash price, is another approach.

Surcharging and Dual Pricing are two of the pricing models PayLink can put a business on, and it says they can eliminate up to 100% of credit card processing fees for the merchant. They work by having the customer who chooses to pay by card bear the cost, and they must follow card-brand rules and state law. If you also offer ACH without a fee, customers get a real choice and can see what each method costs. Confirm current card-brand and state rules with your processor or attorney before you add any fee.

A simple way to decide

SituationLead withWhy
Small consumer payments at the end of a jobCardInstant approval, and the fee gap is small
Recurring monthly chargesACH debitLow cost every month, and no card expiry dates to chase
B2B invoices in the thousandsACHThe fee stays flat while a card fee grows
Customers who insist on cards for large invoicesCard with a compliant surcharge, where permittedThe card cost moves to the customer who chose it
Goods or keys released on paymentCard, or wait out the ACH return windowA card is approved while you watch, though it can still be disputed later

For how ACH itself works, start with what an ACH payment is.

Sources

Talk to us

Talk to us about the ways you take payments.

Book a free consultation and talk through how this applies to your business. If you have a recent processing statement, bring it along.